Showing posts with label column. Show all posts
Showing posts with label column. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Technology And The Ruling Party

gattaca



"Power tends to corrupt," said Lord Acton, "and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men."



The sexism needs updating but the sentiment remains true. That's been all too obvious this week, during which the powers that be did their damnedest to protect their once-secret surveillance programs...while the NSA responded to Freedom Of Information Act requests with the claim "There's no central method to search [internal NSA emails] at this time."



@rezendi In related news, NSA says it's never come across the term "dogfooding" in any of its data trawling, & doesn't know its definition.-
Lun Esex (@LunaticSX) July 24, 2013



The black-comedy message is clear: surveillance is something that the powerful do to the powerless, in their own perfect secrecy. Two-way transparency is but a pipe dream in the minds of civil libertarians. Which puts me in mind of science-fiction guru Charles Stross's recent blog post A Bad Dream:



Is the United Kingdom a one party state? [...] I'm nursing a pet theory. Which is that there are actually four main political parties in Westminster: the Conservatives, Labour, the Liberal Democrats, and the Ruling Party. The Ruling Party is a meta-party...it always wins every election, because whichever party wins is led by members of the Ruling Party, who have more in common with each other than with the back bench dinosaurs who form the rump of their notional party [...] Any attempt at organizing a transfer of power that does not usher in a new group of Ruling Party faces risks being denounced as Terrorism.



Of course in America this is old news. The one thing that the Tea Party and the Occupy movement have in common is their desire to throw the Ruling Party bums out of Washington. It's an accepted axiom in American politics that anyone who has been in Washington too long is suspect and probably corrupt. (More than 75% of Americans think their political parties are corrupt.)



The wave of hope that drove Obama into office was fuelled in part by the belief that he wasn't a member of the Ruling Party. Well, even if he wasn't then, he sure is now. That's what usually happens to successful politicians:



The GOP establishment: Obama is a tyrant, except in the areas where we want to give him sweeping unilateral power to exercise in secret.-
Conor Friedersdorf (@conor64) July 26, 2013



Nancy Pelosi in 2005: Patriot Act "a massive invasion of privacy" 1.usa.gov/1bOHdyZ Today, she voted to let that invasion continue.-
Trevor Timm (@trevortimm) July 24, 2013



Similarly, the recent spate of antigovernment street protests in Turkey, Brazil, etc., are-arguably-protests against the various international incarnations of the Ruling Party. As Slavoj i ek writes in the London Review of Books:



What we first took as a failure fully to apply a noble principle (democratic freedom) is in fact a failure inherent in the principle itself. This realisation - that failure may be inherent in the principle we're fighting for - is a big step in a political education. Representatives of the ruling ideology roll out their entire arsenal to prevent us from reaching this radical conclusion.



i ek's a Marxist, and I'm a staunch capitalist, but even I have to admit that he may be on to something there. it's possible that multiparty democracy suffers from an inherent and fundamental flaw: the eventual installation of an entrenched, parasitical Ruling Party.



So, of course, as a techie who instinctively thinks in terms of hacking and fixing systems, I immediately find myself wondering: is there a technical fix? Can better technology save us from the Ruling Parties, or at least alleviate some of our governments' more glaring flaws? Or will technology further entrench and empower them?



These days it's hard for Silicon Valley to look at Washington with anything other than dismay trending towards horror, along with a powerful sense of "there has to be a better way." I expect that's why people have seriously called for Google to buy Detroit. I suspect that's what Larry Page had in mind, at least in part, when he mused aloud about the desirability of a mad science island untrammeled by antiquated laws and politics, where we could experiment with new and better systems:



We're changing quickly, but some of our institutions, like some laws, aren't changing with that. The laws [about technology] can't be right if it's 50 years old - that's before the Internet. Maybe more of us need to go into other areas to help them improve and understand technology.



Google is, after all, the apotheosis of the Valley; a company that muses about offering eternal youth to its employees somewhere down the road, a company that oozes scientific method. Doesn't that sound a whole lot better than the Ruling Party? Doesn't it seem like the best thing we could do is import the Google Way to Washington, and turn our government into a genuine technocracy?



Sorry. No. Silicon Valley thinks of itself as built on merit, innovation, iteration, and rational thought, and to some extent it is, but its worldview can be even more blinkered and bubble-bound than that of the Ruling Party. Technology does not solve all of the world's problems, and it's dangerous hubris to think that it might. Rational thought is a flawed tool in a world full of irrational people. And most of all, power corrupts; anyone who replaces the Ruling Party will probably eventually become a member.



But on the other hand, avoiding politics and/or pretending that it has nothing to do with us is no longer an option for the tech industry. Edward Snowden has shown us that much. We have become too important and too powerful. As I wrote here almost three years ago:



You probably don't want to read about political idiocy here, and I can't blame you. But it may be time for the tech industry to start paying much more attention to the political world, because as Wikileaks vividly illustrates, these days almost every political issue has tech aspects-and hence, down the road, tech repercussions.



Can't help but think I wasn't wrong. But that doesn't mean the tech industry should be trying to directly shape what happens in Washington and Westminster. We provide tools; we don't dig trenches. That's not what we're good at. (Witness FWD.us.) Instead we should collectively be trying to ensure that tomorrow's technologies, and tomorrow's networks, support individual authority (and privacy), rather than building centralized panopticons which increase and cement the existing hegemonies.



I realize that this all sounds simultaneously paranoid and na ve. But I believe we're nearing a crucial point at which, depending on a myriad of separate decisions ultimately made by individual people, tomorrow's technologies can-and will-either increase or diminish our individual and collective freedoms by a very significant degree. The direction we will take seems finely balanced, and could still go either way. So keep your fingers crossed, and your eyes wide open.



Postscript: I'll be in Las Vegas this week to cover the Black Hat and DefCon security conferences. I'm not entirely sure yet what kind of reportage I'll be filing, but if you're interested in occasional sardonic tweets from Sin City, follow me on Twitter.



Monday, February 24, 2014

How Apple Gets At-Home Workers To Work

Apple At-Home Worker Image



Editor's note: Ashley Verrill is a software analyst for Software Advice, as well as the Managing Editor for the Customer Service Investigator blog.



When a leaked memo broke the news earlier this year that Yahoo was ending its work-from-home program, CEO Marissa Mayer was both lauded and lambasted for the decision. Companies such as Best Buy followed suit by announcing they too would end their flexible work options, while some industry observers called the move an "epic fail.



The fact of the matter is, while not every remote worker is happier, more productive, and produces better quality work, as some have purported, telecommuting offers indisputable benefits for certain types of businesses. Apple, for example, permanently employs a massive network of remote customer support agents (dubbed At-Home Apple Advisors), saving them the huge real estate expense of a call center. At the same time, their recruiters can draw from an enormous talent pool since location isn't a factor, and weather never prevents "advisors" from coming to work.



But running a team this way doesn't come without challenges, chief among them being effectively training people in disparate locations. But Apple makes it work. I know this, because I recently emailed more than 40 current and former "Advisors" on LinkedIn to learn how. (Apple refused to comment. They are notoriously tight-lipped on strategy). The methods in every case were intense, sometimes sort of silly, and at other times borderline extreme. As one employee commented in a community thread, "I can honestly say the job was probably one of the most stressful I have ever had, and I used to counsel drug addicts and felons!"



For starters, according to the advisors I spoke to, Apple doesn't tell trainees until after they're "hired" that the four-week, 8 a.m.-5 p.m. training program is actually a testing period. The curriculum is broken into four, one-week sections that are a mix of live instruction and self-paced modules in iDesk. Then at the end of each week, everyone takes an exam. They have two chances to hit the grading benchmark (two advisors said this was 89 percent, one said it was 80 percent), before they are kicked out of the program. So immediately, workers have an impetus not only to pay attention, but to keep the job once it's final because they worked so hard to get there.



Next, Apple uses a variety of tactics to ensure that would-be advisors are actually at their computers while training is going on. For example, trainers deliver regular prompts to each person throughout live instruction. These can be questions, requests for input, or just a cue for the trainee to click on. One former advisor I spoke to said Apple monitors mouse movements. If your mouse doesn't move in a certain amount of time, then you're sent a prompt. If you still don't respond within 30 seconds, the trainer might actually call your cell phone.



In addition to these prompts, trainers can ask the class to turn on their cameras for group discussion at any moment, making it immediately clear if someone isn't at their desk. Also, many of the test questions are worded in such a way that the trainee would only know the answer if they participated in all the past week's activities.



All of these tactics are extremely impactful, not only for ensuring attendance, but fostering competition. Every advisor I spoke to reported never missing a session (though several mentioned other trainees dropping out, or being kicked out because of test scores). This was in part because the entire class sees when someone doesn't respond to a prompt and when they fail a test.



In addition to ensuring attendance, Apple uses team psychology to keep workers engaged during and after the training period. Programs are taught to groups of 20-100 people who all live within 100 miles of its many "hub cities." Often between instruction, the trainer asks the group to talk about themselves. They ask them about what they did that weekend, whether they have any pets, or even "why doesn't everyone send the group a picture of what they're having for lunch?" Some classes even had crazy hat day (that's the silly part, I mentioned above).



This teamwork is also enforced by breaking the class into smaller groups for mock calls near the end of the program. One person in the sub-group fields a hypothetical customer call, while the entire team is asked to give feedback after the exercise is over. Many of the advisors reported regularly chatting on the computer, or even over the phone with classmates during and after instruction was over.



While some of these strategies were reminiscent of team-building exercises I did at summer camp, they worked. Two of the people I interviewed no longer work as an Apple advisor, but still keep in contact with a few people that were in their training group.



Finally, Apple creates buy-in from the team by enforcing company culture. The first few days of training are dedicated to describing the company's history, the Cupertino campus culture, and what it was like working with Steve Jobs. Before training starts, each advisor is sent a care package that might have a T-shirt, plaque, mug, gift cards and other keepsakes demonstrating that they are "part of the Apple family," as one person put it.



After training, workers begin a job that is extremely intense. One certified Apple trainer told me that managers closely scrutinize every call, and advisors are required to maintain a nearly perfect customer satisfaction score (among other metrics used to measure performance). All of this, and the advisors make between $9-$12 an hour (according to the advisors I spoke to).



Outsiders would probably argue that Apple's training program and high work expectations aren't really feasible for other support organizations - people would quit after the first day. I'd be inclined to agree. In the same way that customers will pay three times as much for their technology, workers will endure much more to get Apple on their resume and be "part of the family."



So, while companies who manage teams permanently off-site can still realize the same benefits I mentioned at the outset - savings on real estate and a broader reach for recruiting - they may not be able to establish a remote team that is as effective as Apple's. Only Apple can demand this level of intensity, because as one advisor put it, "Apple has no qualms with saying if you are not the best, you can always work somewhere else. They make that abundantly clear."



[Image via Jeremy Jenum]



Wednesday, February 19, 2014

What Games Are: Self-Publishing On Console Will Not Create The Next SuperCell. But Microconsoles Might.

Screen Shot 2013-07-28 at 2.43.08 PM



Editor's note: Tadhg Kelly is a veteran game designer, creator of leading game design blog What Games Are and creative director of Jawfish Games. You can follow him on Twitter here.



To the joy of many, Microsoft announced another Xbox One pivot: Rather than try to maintain a fortress of solitude, the console will support indie publishing. You'll be able to use your console as a dev kit (traditionally dev kit licenses could be very expensive) to make and publish your games. Microsoft even promises to remove some of the category barriers that segregated indie games to a backwater page in the Xbox dashboard.



These moves can be read in two ways. The first is largely as a reaction to Sony. Sony has been flirting with the indie developer community for a while, quietly building up relationships and facilitating the publishing of a number of games such as Journey and Thomas Was Alone. As part of PS4 the company has significant plans to allow small developers to self-publish on the system, although still under a dev kit model. It promises to send free kits to developers that need them.



The second read is to consider these moves in light of wider trends. Outside of giant thousand-man studios and tiny indies, most mid-sized gaming companies are nowhere within 100 kilometers of consoles these days. There's just no place for them in a sector that values its 20m+ unit hits, and they can't afford to compete at that level. All of those people have shifted to mobile, tablet or social instead, where they are finding success.



The move to attract indies sits semi-uncomfortably. The console industry is used to acting like a car showroom, developing specific pieces of beautiful game content and then engaging in a large sales push toward success. Fans of consoles (including many developers) are also used to this model, and tend to think of this activity as "real games," as well as the most economically significant activity in the industry. Much as Hollywood still thinks that box office means something, console game executives tend to be more impressed by stories involving unit sales rather than residuals.



That showroom mentality is what led Microsoft down the path of making Xbox One into a mega-hub, which nobody understood, or Sony make a very similar thrust with PlayStation 3. The pivots away from those big plays may at first glance seem like attempts to atone or to broaden out their relationships with game makers, but I tend to think otherwise. What they're actually about is developing a few show-bikes to go alongside the show-cars.


Indies vs Independents


There are several meanings of the term "indie." For some it simply means financially independent, able to make games and revenue and be self-sustaining. For others the term is political, expressive of points of view and meaning. This second version is far more popular in the games press because it has more of an emotional component. Indies stand for something and become heroes fighting an unspecified "man."



It may surprise you, but in the console-ist view the political kind of indie game is more desirable because it ticks the art-game box. Art games are rarely expected to make their money back, and certainly not to become big franchises. Yet there's a lot of value in having them. If you can have a few notables like Jonathan Blow talking up your platform, a few Phil Fishes and a few "thatgamecompanys" making signature games, then this is a great story. It aligns you with the kind of story seen in Indie Game: The Movie and at GDC. Most important is that it gets the press on side, which is hugely important in the mutually assured destruction of console platforms. Appearing to be indie is worth acres of PR.



At the same time, supporting a few such indies allows platforms to retain their essential power. While PC gaming has always reserved much more power to the developer and treated hardware makers as little more than component makers, console gaming has always worked the other way. The console is the main brand and the platform story. The games all appear on the console with the holder's say-so. The publishing model places the console brand front and center, and the games are in support, and the market tribally responds along those lines.



Taken in that vein, the modern console industry's understanding of allowing indies to enter into its playpen is pointed but they are not embracing an ecosystem any time soon. From the standpoint of where they've been, modest steps to change their model may seem like great leaps for Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo. Like TV executives who are still tentative about streaming, there's a sense of not going too fast for fear of losing everything.



This is why Microsoft's newfound message of developer liberation is still pretty garbled. The exact plans for how Xbox One will go indie-friendly come across as a bit hazy. They smack of a recent decision at the executive level which will need some thoughtful re-engineering time to figure out on the practical level, so don't expect it for launch. Also how it reconciles with some other showroom features (like the heavy push on mainstream TV) is anyone's guess.



Not to let Sony off the hook, its plans for indie liberation are similarly convoluted. Sony still wants some forms of concept approval, which - even though the company promises a speedy turnaround - still sounds every bit as ludicrous as Roku wanting concept approval for movies it streams. It should make any developer pause and think seriously about what it implies.



Yet the bigger issue is that both plans are not enough. They do not represent change real enough that indies in the first sense of the word (financially viable) would find attractive. It's also woefully out of step with just how far games have come. Developers are far more empowered today than they have been since the days of microcomputers in the 80s and are not keen to sacrifice that freedom.


You Are Free To Do What We Tell You


It used to be imperative to placate Sony, Nintendo or Microsoft for any game to have a chance of being published. This was expensive between concept approvals, extensive technical requirements and laborious quality assurance and certification processes. But what could you do? They were the gatekeepers, it was largely a relationships business, and that was that.



Even when they moved into digital markets they were choosy, taking an active role in content selection and publishing. Games were released on schedules to give a window for sales to build and platforms were managed like topiary. Not too many games of one genre or another, just a few key ones and a heavy sense of curation. All very bonsai.



Then Apple and Facebook upended that model with something more organic and irrevocably changed how developers thought of success. Success was no longer to be like Jonathan Blow or Ubisoft. It became being like SuperCell. The console industry has never been able to fully understand the depth of that shift.



The way that developers approach making games on Facebook, iOS and Android is radically different to how things used to be when console platforms (and PCs) was all there was. They just do it, no dev kits, relationships, publishing schedules or concept approvals required. They may need to pass some curation (particularly from Apple) but those conditions tend to be far narrower in scope than anything the console industry ever imposed. Essentially don't crash, no porn, no defamation and you're good to go.



That new model is the one that breeds true independent game development success. The bonsai paradigm of consoles prevents developers from expanding too much, meaning that a thatgamecompany gets to make cool games but not really grow (if they want to, of course). Whereas the iOS/Android/Facebook model gives birth to Rovios and Zyngas (in happier times perhaps). When platforms get out of the way and let software be software, software becomes wildly successful and the platform itself grows.



Obviously Rovio is an extreme case, but many other smaller studios have managed to forge their own destinies in a similar fashion. Studios like Spry Fox and NimbleBit make the games they want to make, how they want to make them, with whatever business model they desire, and it's no big deal. So they are free to innovate and they do. Same for us at Jawfish.


Enter the Micros


Console makers do realize that they've painted themselves into a corner, want to change and get some press goodwill. Yet not to the extent that they detonate their existing business. Especially not when many of their fans prefer to cheer for stasis and buy into predictable franchises over innovation.



I don't envy them, but that gap is why microconsoles are a real threat. OUYA, GamePop, GameStick, Mad Catz and whatever Google might be cooking up are relatively unencumbered by old constraints, and therefore able to empower indies in the first sense. The fact that they're mostly using a common operating system helps, but their main advantage is the potential flexibility and the focus that being simple provides.



The first generation of microconsole hardware is less than stellar. Of course it is. The idea is brand new and still finding its way. The OUYA's joypad, for example, isn't good. The processors for most microconsoles are probably underpowered, and there are lots of early firmware and operating system issues. Look past these early-phase issues, however, and take in the longer view.



Microconsoles can iterate on hardware quickly, like phone makers, where Sony is stuck with a fixed spec for the next seven years with PS4. Big consoles have to be static because big publishers (like Activision) need the spec to be stable enough to master in order to make the next Call of Duty. A SuperCell, on the other hand, doesn't. An iPad doesn't. Indeed most every other form of electronics has figured out how to move to an annualized cycle except console makers.



Beyond hardware issues the next issue is the customer. Who are microconsoles for? Everyone. Everyone who likes to play games cheaply, for fun, with simple controllers and low (or free) prices. As we've seen on phone, tablet and Facebook, that translates to a hell of a lot of people. And before we get too worried about TV being somehow special in this regard, consider that that is a self-cyclical piece of thinking born of consoles being pretty bad as devices. They are only now getting into the idea that maybe they should have power/resume states like every other device you've owned since the turn of the millennium. Part of the reason why they have that special gamer aura is because they are a hassle. There's no reason for micros to follow the same path.


Power Shifts


The future that I see for console gaming is one where hardware incrementally cedes power to software. Pushed by microconsoles offering a vastly cheaper option on the one hand, and developers of incredible games with the right business models on the other, the prospect of all three current console platform holders being reduced to only vertically satisfying their core fans is very real. The prospect of big publishers taking a bath is also very real.



It will take a couple of iterations to get their hardware and business models right. It may take the entrance of a big player like Google or Samsung to validate it (much as Amazon did for ebooks). There will also be that initial flurry of press coverage that will swamp all channels with talk of PS4 vs X1 (and ill-advisedly lamenting Nintendo) for the next 18 months. That will cover over the real story to an extent, allowing OUYA et al room to breathe and pivot.



But in the medium term? The new SuperCells will not be coming from these revamped "indie" console offerings. They'll come from a very different kind of device entirely.



(If you'd like to hear more, come see me talk about microconsoles some more at Casual Connect this week in San Francisco.)



Saturday, October 12, 2013

Twitter does not hire enough women, but it’s less about gender than experience

twitter 520x245 Twitter does not hire enough women, but its less about gender than experience




Twitter has been criticized over the weekend for a revelation from its IPO filing that the New York Times reported on - the company only has one woman sitting among its top officials.



That would be the general counsel, Vijaya Gadde, who took over five weeks ago when the previous guy unexpectedly resigned.



The company also has a lack of senior women represented across its senior positions.



The social networking site has already drawn a lot of flak for this fact from all over the tech world and then CEO Dick Costolo decided to chip in his two cents' worth. He took to (where else) Twitter to make a comment about Vivek Wadhwa, the academic who spoke to the New York Times and commented that Twitter possessed the "elite arrogance of the Silicon Valley mafia" and "male chauvinistic thinking."



@rich1 Vivek Wadhwa is the Carrot Top of academic sources.



- dick costolo (@dickc) October 5, 2013



For those who don't catch the Carrot Top reference, it apparently points to the American comedian of the same name - and it seems like Costolo was making fun of Wadhwa for being too over-the-top (as seen in another tweet he made).



@anildash huh??? I was making fun of his propensity for silly hyperbole. I didn't say anything about the topic or even reference it!



- dick costolo (@dickc) October 5, 2013



By now, all of you must surely be thinking: what a dickhead Costolo is.



173196945 730x575 Twitter does not hire enough women, but its less about gender than experience




The gender gap in tech companies is a hot-button issue that people have been harping on for years. Why is it that tech companies tend to hire more men than women? There must be some chauvinistic attitude at play here.



However, the gender imbalance in a tech company is really way more than just finding (capable) women and putting them on board among top officials. Of course Twitter should set an example as a progressive tech company, but honestly the problem goes way deeper than that - it goes back into the depths of history where women have been traditionally molded into certain roles that affect their study choices, which eventually influence their career choices.


It's about skill sets, not about gender


First up, I want to say that I obviously would appreciate having more women in the tech scene.



However, in the midst of all the anger about Twitter propagating the gender imbalance by not wanting to hire more women, there is a propensity to forget about what is more important when it comes to selecting someone to be in the top ranks: talent.



The New York Times article states that according to research firm Catalyst, only about 2 percent of women have a degree in a high-tech field, and only 5.7 percent of employed women in the US hold a job in the computer industry.



As a tech company, a large part of Twitter's employees would obviously be hired for the technical side - and therefore in turn executives.



What is interesting here is that there simply is a supply-side problem, as already pointed out by Twitter's CTO Adam Messinger back in March when he did an interview with the Times. Only 2 percent of women chose to get a degree that teaches high-tech skills, that is the technical know-how needed in bigger numbers by a tech company. Is it any wonder there aren't that many software engineers who are women - when so many women did not choose to major in such a specialization at college?



It is natural that women who work in tech companies tend to veer toward the non-technical side of things, considering what they studied. Case in point: Twitter hires several vice presidents on the business side who are women - but not on the technical side.



180784317 730x485 Twitter does not hire enough women, but its less about gender than experience




I do believe that despite the small number of women who studied the technical know-hows of technology, there are still many women out there who are talented software engineers, for example. However, with so many tech companies trying to address the gender issue and hiring them away, it is not easy to find someone who is the exact right fit for your company, and happens to be a woman at the same time.



The rule of thumb for companies is simply to hire the most talented person available. Of course, many think men will hire like for like, therefore perpetuating the dominance of men sitting among the top positions at tech companies. However, I am assuming Twitter was not dumb enough to give up on a woman with equal qualifications and suitability as a man who was running for the same position.



Costolo tries to explain it (though he might need to practise having more tact) in a tweet to Wadhwa.



@wadhwa you're not seeing my point. you give people an easy out by just checking a box. The issues are much bigger than checking any 1 box.



- dick costolo (@dickc) October 5, 2013


Change requires a lot of time


Of course, there is much to change about the status quo. However, what needs to change requires a lot of effort not only on these tech companies' part, but also on society's part. Basically, if you have more women heading into college and specializing in high-tech skills that will eventually benefit these companies, you will have no excuse not to hire a woman. And this issue of education is what needs to be addressed and changed ultimately, not the tech companies' hiring policy.



After all, any company in its right mind should definitely include these two very important criteria when hiring: talent and suitability.



To overturn the trend now of a lack of women representatives in the tech scene requires a whole generation to be educated in a different approach from the previous generations - parents need to be more open about letting their daughters explore their geeky side, the curriculum needs to be geared toward equality for all subjects in school, and teachers need to be more proactive about developing talents in their students regardless of gender.



In fact, change has started to emerge. Many women in the tech world have started to be thrust into the limelight - and for good reasons. Marissa Mayer, who heads Yahoo, is one. She has taken over a major tech company and is steering it through difficult waters. Another one would be Sheryl Sandberg, the chief operating officer of Facebook. As a woman myself, I am immensely proud of them.



169137327 730x494 Twitter does not hire enough women, but its less about gender than experience




Many say that Twitter should be a role model and take the step forward in increasing its number of female hires, especially in senior positions. I believe that if and when they find women who are suitable for certain roles, they will do so.



We should have more faith in the fact that women aren't getting hired just because we are women, and there is really no need to focus on gender. It all boils down to talent and suitable skill sets, and if a woman has enough of these versus a male competitor, she could thrash him for sure.



Leave gender in the background. Focus on skills instead. I don't want to be hired because I'm a woman. I want to be hired because I'm the best at what I do - compared with other women, and men. And if there is so much attention being given to efforts that try to balance the gender equation, it may lead women to wonder: am I being placed in this role as a token female, or is it really because of my capabilities?



Headline image via Leon Neal/AFP/Getty Images, other images via Getty Images, Getty Images and Getty Images


Monday, April 8, 2013

You Won’t See Facebook’s Graph Search On iPhone Or Android Anytime Soon


Editor's note: Tareq Ismail is the UX lead at Maluuba, a personal assistant app for Android and Windows Phone that was a Battlefield participant at TechCrunch Disrupt SF 2012. Follow him on Twitter @tareqismail.



The release of Facebook’s Graph Search has raised much discussion among technology pundits and investors. One of the biggest questions surrounding the highly anticipated feature is its availability on mobile.



After all, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has said on a number of occasions that Facebook is a mobile company. “On mobile we are going to make a lot more money than on desktop,” he said at TechCruch Disrupt SF 2012, adding “a lot more people have phones than computers, and mobile users are more likely to be daily active users." Facebook understands mobile’s importance, so why wouldn’t it offer Graph Search for Android and iPhone from the start?



It's simple: Graph Search for mobile would need to incorporate speech, which is a different beast altogether.



Many of the examples given during the Graph Search keynote contained long sentences, which are not easy to type on a mobile device. Think of the example “My college friends who like roller blading that live in Palo Alto.” Search engines like Google get around this on mobile by offering autofill suggestions, but their suggestions come from billions of queries. For Facebook, since their search is based on hundreds of individual values like “fencing” or “college friends” specific to each user and not a group, autofill suggestions will often not be useful, or worse, will require a lot of tapping and swiping to drill down to the full request.



What’s more is that Graph Search queries are designed to be written out naturally in full-form sentences with verbs, pronouns, etc., which is 0something that keyword search engines like Google do not need. If you’re looking for sushi places to eat on Google, it’s a five-character search for the keyword “sushi.” With Graph Search, Facebook wants to show you sushi results refined by a group of your friends, so the same search would require writing out “sushi restaurants my friends have been to” or “sushi restaurants my friends like.” That’s a lot more typing.



It’s clear that on mobile, Graph Search would need to be powered by speech to make it most effective. No one will want to type out such long sentences. Not to mention, with services like Google Now and Siri, people will come to expect control through speech.



Supporting speech is a different problem altogether than what they’ve solved so far and they’ll have to do a lot more work until it’s available on any major mobile platform. Here are four reasons why.


Speech Recognition Doesn’t Come Cheap

If time is money, then speech recognition is very expensive. It’s well-known that it requires a considerable amount of investment to develop and no one knows this better than Apple and Google.



Apple chose to not make their own speech recognition but rather license Nuance’s technology for Siri. Nuance has spent over 20 years perfecting their speech recognition; it’s not an easy task and they’ve had to acquire a number of companies along the way.



Google, on the other hand, chose to develop their own speech recognition and needed to build a clever system to collect data to catch up to Nuance. The system, called Google 411, set up a phone number where people could call in from landlines and feature phones to ask for local results. Once they got the data they needed, they shut down the service and used it to build their recognition system. It’s taken a company like Google, who masters search, over three years to come to where they are now with their speech recognition.



Even if it takes Facebook half as long to come up with a similarly clever solution, they’ll need to start soon for it to be released any time in the next year.


Names Are Facebook’s Strength And Speech Recognition’s Weakness

One of Facebook’s early successes has been names. The company’s algorithms to return the most relevant person when making a search for a friend played a key role in its early success. People are accustomed to saying “add me on Facebook” without the need to specify a username or handle, an advantage that makes their entry into speech that much harder.



Names are speech recognition’s biggest challenge. Speech recognition relies on having a dictionary or list of expected words that are paired to sample voice data given to the system. That’s why most engines do really well when recognizing common English words but have such a hard time with out-of-the-norm names and varying pronunciations. Facebook has hundreds of thousands of names to deal with and it’s a key part of their experience, so they’ll need to master the domain for it to be useful for their users. Now, one could argue that having access to all these names may give Facebook the edge to solving this problem, but they’ll need to work on a solution for some time for it to become anywhere near acceptable.


Supporting Natural Language Isn’t Easy

The final piece of the puzzle may be the most difficult: supporting natural language is really, really hard. Working at natural language processing company Maluuba, I can attest to just how hard a problem this is to solve. Natural language processing is the ability to understand and extract meaning from naturally formed sentences.



This also includes pairing sentences that have the same meaning but are said differently. For example, with Graph search, I can type “friends that like sushi” and it shows a list of my friends who have identified sushi as an interest, but if I type “friends that like eating sushi” it looks for the interest "eating sushi" — which none of my friends have listed — and it returns zero results. In reality, both sentences mean the same thing but are worded differently. Understanding natural language involves understanding the real intent behind a request, not just its literal intent.



On a desktop browser, they may be able to get users to learn how to search in specific sentence templates, especially with the help of autofill suggestions. But for speech it’s nearly impossible. People ask for things differently almost every time; even the same person can ask for the same request in a different fashion when speaking. Ask 10 of your friends how they would search for nearby sushi restaurants. I have no doubt most, if not all, responses will be different from one another.



Now, they could fix the sushi example I gave earlier but that may cause false positives with other aspects of the system. Understanding natural language requires large data sets and complex machine learning to get right, something that Facebook’s Graph Search team may be investigating but will not be able to master any time soon. It’s just not a simple problem to solve. That’s why Apple jumped into a bidding war to buy Siri, which at its core is a natural language processor. To put into perspective how difficult it was, Siri spun out of the DARPA project that took over five years to build with over 300 top researchers from the best universities in the country.


Languages, Languages, Languages

Facebook has over a billion users who collectively speak hundreds of different languages. Facebook has said they’re beginning their launch with English. How long until all billion users’ languages are supported for the desktop? And since speech is significantly harder, how long until those users are supported on mobile? It’s one thing to support hundreds of languages through text and a much harder thing to support it through speech. This will be the problem they face for the next decade.



Facebook acknowledges that their future lies in mobile. Mobile begs for Graph Search to be powered by speech, something that Facebook simply cannot do yet. I have no doubt they will but it most definitely won’t be to any acceptable quality anytime soon. They’ve taken the first step but they have a long journey ahead of them.



Backed Or Whacked: Revenge Of The Dumb Watch


Editor's note: Ross Rubin is principal analyst at Reticle Research and blogs at Techspressive. Each column will look at crowdfunded products that have either met or missed their funding goals. Follow him on Twitter @rossrubin.



Last year, Kickstarter launched a bumper crop of smart watches that connect via Bluetooth to your smartphone. The field was led by the record-setting Pebble, but also included products such as Cookoo, the MetaWatch Strata, and Martian, all of which have shipped by now. Recently, though, a number of timepieces have surfaced that bring us back to basics when it comes to telling time.



Backed: CST-01. Briefly mentioned in last week's column amid CES alum Tethercell, the CST-01 is certainly a high-tech timepiece that tackles several challenges with smartwatches — girth, complexity and short battery life. Like the recently shipped Pebble watch and the still-delayed Touch Time by Phosphor, the CST-01 uses e-paper technology to display the time. Unlike those watches, though, that's about all it does — no Bluetooth, no touchscreen, no launching of poison darts into the neck of the enemy spy.



The result is what project originator Central Standard Time claims is the world's thinnest watch at 0.8 mm, one that dispenses with traditional straps and clasps with its bangle design. Unfortunately, the slim profile makes for some compromises. The watch requires a base station in order to be charged, which needs to take place about once per month, and the power cell is slated to burn out in about 15 years. Forget about passing this on to the next generation that futurists say will be able to tell time simply by looking at their phones.



Thin is in and the CST-01 has already more than quadrupled its goal with about 10 days left to go in the campaign. Watches are still available to backers in black or what passes for white in the e-paper world for $129 and are slated to ship in September.



Backed: The Big Face Woody. This creation of Hawaii-based NFNT (pronounced like the synonym for “eternity,” not “baby”) can claim the cheekiest name for a Kickstarter design product since the MorningHead hair-moistening aid of a year ago. The Big Face Woody (endorsed neither by Mr. Allen, Mr. Harrelson or Mr. Woodpecker) is a watch made wholly of bamboo, save for the steel clasp.



Bamboo is one of the most favored crowdfunding materials up there with silicone and aluminum. The wood, so notes the Kickstarter campaign page, is strong and lightweight. The Big Face Woody weighs in at only 50 grams, (although that’s still four times the weight of the wispy CST-01's 12 grams) and eco-friendly. The social consciousness of the design team is also reflected in a couple of paragraphs talking about student financial hardships, although there is no direct connection made between raising the funds and helping those students — even by employing them to help make the watches.



Like the CST-01, the Big Face Woody is water-resistant but not waterpoof. NFNT has met all its stretch goals, having collected more than six times its original $11,000 funding goal. The watches, in a range of face sizes, can be preordered for $75 with an extra fiver netting you a date function. Early backers can grab their Woodys as early as March; it would surely be inauspicious for a watchmaker to ship late.



Whacked: Heritage Watch. It's not unusual for mechanical watches to be offered to backers for hundreds of dollars; such is the case for the recently listed Coastliner watch, which can be claimed for 375. Things seemed to be going well for the effort, led by New York-based Field and Crew. The Heritage Watch would be distinguished by a "smart pin" system that would enable quick changes of wrist straps without any tools. Its entry reward tier included the watch and two bands for $199, a steep discount over the estimated $500 retail price. The campaign had raised over $16,000 — well above its $9,000 goal — and was on pace to pick up more before its February 17 ending date.



Alas, this looks like another Kickstarter campaign that has gone askew. The site has suspended the campaign and the project owner has not provided any official updates since the suspension, although backer chatter indicates that he has claimed he has not heard many specifics from Kickstarter on why funding was suspended while vowing to go to other sites to raise money if it is not resumed. The stoppage may have something to do with the similarities that have cropped up between images of the Heritage Watch and images of other watches.



Things don't look promising, as the website for Field & Crew has gone offline. Perhaps "Chris" has been inspired by the watch-worthy words of REO Speedwagon when they sang, "I believe it's time for me to fly." If the project has turned out to be a scam, though, no money will have been lost by backers, as they have not yet been charged.